Get a Free Quote!

Metal Roof vs. Shingles

It’s fair to say that the roof is an important part of a building. In reality, the roof is what protects your building from the elements. Considering that, it might be nice to know a little bit more about modern roofs. That way, when you need a new one, you can make an informed decision.

When it comes to pitched roofs, there are two material options that tend to gain favor over the rest. Those materials are shingles and metal. Here at Redline Roofing, we offer both shingle and metal roof installation and repairs in Lindale and the entire East Texas area so you can stop searching for “roofers near me“. Let’s compare the two directly to see which might be better for your roof.

Metal Roofs

Metal roofing is extremely popular for commercial applications, but in the last two decades or so it has been used widely for residential roofing as well. You’ll see more metal roofs on homes today than at any prior point in history.

Pros of Using Metal

The number one reason to get a metal roof is its durability. They can handle intense storms and a lot of abuse. Metal roofs have a long lifespan with proper maintenance. Because metal roofs last so long, they tend to be the economical choice in the long term.

On top of that, metal is more environmentally friendly. The majority of metal roofing can be recycled. It also produces less waste over the life of the roof, making it a sustainable choice.

Metal roofing panels come in a variety of colors. The finish of colored metal often comes with a warranty from the manufacturer.

Metal roofs can save you money on your insurance premiums.

Lastly, metal roofing offers unique aesthetics. Modern metal roofs are gorgeous and captivating.

The Downsides of Metal Roofs

For all of those pros, there are legitimate reasons to consider nonmetal roofing options. The first is that metal can be difficult to work with unless you have an experienced company who installs them frequently as we do here at Redline Roofing.

Metal roofs also cost a lot more money upfront. You might be saving in the long run, but the up-front cost for metal can be more than twice the cost of asphalt for standard R-panel roofing. Standing seam roofing is even higher.

Even though the metal panels last many years, metal roofs do not come without maintenance. In the hot East Texas temperatures, the rubber washers under the screws can deteriorate resulting in the need for the replacement of screws. We usually see a need for screw replacement every 8-12 years.

If you ever develop a leak in your metal roof, it can sometimes be difficult to locate the source potentially resulting in a higher cost of repair.

Even though metal roofs are durable and can lower your insurance premiums, insurance companies often have a cosmetic exclusion listed for dings. If you have hail damage that is deemed cosmetic, your insurance company will likely deny your claim.


Shingles are the most common roofing style in the United States. Asphalt shingles are quicker to install and can save you money upfront.

Best Attributes of Shingles

The main reason you still see so many shingle roofs is that they have a lower material and installation cost. Shingle roofs are easy to repair and maintain. 30-year laminated shingles are very durable and can last a long time. Asphalt shingles come in a variety of colors and styles to match any home.

Class 4 shingles can save you money on your insurance premiums.

Lastly, shingles are less noisy than metal roofs in storms.

Where Shingles Leave You Wanting

Holding shingles back are a few well-established cons. Typically, shingle roofs last 15 to 30 years barring extreme weather. They are not lifetime roofs. Because of that, they will need complete replacement more often than a metal roof.

Whether you choose metal or shingles, you need someone to install your new roof. For that, you can turn to Redline Roofing. Contact us today. We’ll take a look at your roof and give you a free quote. We’ll make sure you have access to all of the best roofing options, and when we install your new roof, you’ll know that it was done by qualified professionals.